MENU

WELCOME TO BIG SUGAR BAKESHOP

All our treats are baked fresh daily with the finest ingredients and a truly compulsive degree of care. Drop in or give us a call to see what’s in store. We’re certain you’ll find something to savor.
If you would like to order a large quantity of baked goods or are looking for something special for a celebration, we encourage you to place your order at least 72 hours in advance. Not a big planner? Call us five minutes ahead and we’ll do everything we can to accommodate you!

Good morning

Doughnut Muffin – $3
Scone of the Day – $3
Old-Fashioned Banana Bread – $3 slice
Vegan & Gluten-free Chocolate Banana Loaf – $3 slice
Lemon Pound Cake – $3 slice
Classic Coffee Cake – $3 slice
Seasonal Bundt Cake – $3 slice
Seasonal Pound Cake – $3 slice

Cupcakes

Regular – $3.50 each or $37 per dozen.
Minis – $20 per dozen.
Writing per cupcake – $1 and up.
Image Cupcakes – $4.25
Fondant – $4.50+

Cupcakes available everyday

Just Vanilla
Belgian Chocolate
Red Velvet
Chococcino (Gluten-free)
Vegan Chocolate
Birthday Party
Icebox*
Boston Cream Pie*
Double Coconut*
Carrot Cake*

Monday – Pink Vanilla, Seasonal Special
Tuesday – Cinnamon, Seasonal Special
Wednesday – German Chocolate or Pink Vanilla, Seasonal Special
Thursday – PB&J, Seasonal Special
Friday – Oreo™, Seasonal Special
Saturday – Dalmatian, Hummingbird*, Seasonal Special
Sunday – Hummingbird*, Pink Vanilla, Seasonal Special

*Requires refrigeration

Minis available by the dozen only – Vanilla, Chocolate and Red Velvet assortment – $20

Celebration cakes

6” $40, 9” $65, 12” $135, ½ sheet $135, by the slice $6.25
Just Vanilla
Dark Chocolate
Red Velvet

Custom cakes

We create custom cakes for all occasions. Pricing varies depending on the decor and complexity of the design. Please see our Custom Cake page for details and gallery.

Specialty cakes

6” $45, 9” 75, 12” $155, ½ sheet $155, by the slice $6.25

Boston Cream Pie*
Carrot*
Cinnamon
Confetti – Vanilla or Gluten-free Vanilla
Cookies and Cream
Dalmatian
Double Coconut*
German Chocolate
Gluten-Free Chocolate or Vanilla
Hummingbird*
Lemon Curd*
Neapolitan
Pink Champagne
Pumpkin (Seasonal)
Salted Caramel
Vegan Chocolate

Rainbow Cake
6” $75, 9”$95, 12” $175, ½ sheet $175

Unicorn Cake
6” $80, 9” $120

Buttercream writing is complimentary. There is an additional charge for custom fondant or buttercream design work and tiering of cakes. We require a minimum of 72 hours or more advance notice for special cake orders. Due to the complexity, fondant cakes and tiered cakes require a minimum of 7 days advance notice.

Confectionery

Buckeyes – $1.50
Soda Fountain Fudge – Small Jar $9,95, Large Jar – $19.95
Southern Banana Pudding – $5.25
Chocolate-Dipped Pretzel Trio – $4.50
Cake Pops – $4.25
Gluten-free “All Ding. No Dong” Cake – $4.95
Ice Cream Sandwich (Seasonal) – $5.75
Chocolate-Dipped Strawberries (Seasonal) MP

Cookies, Brownies and More

Chocolate Chip Cookie
Peanut Butter Cookie
State Fair Oatmeal Cookie
Big Sugar Cookie
Reverse Chocolate Cookie
Snickerdoodle Cookie
Custom Sugar Shortbread
Fudge Brownie
Fudge Walnut Brownie
Salted Caramel Brownie*
Oreo™ Brownie
Blondie Brownie
Peanut Butter Brownie
Seven-Layer Bar
Lemon Bar*
Vegan Gluten-Free Brownie

Cookies – $1.50 each , 4 for $5 
Shortbread cookies – Seasonal shapes, price varies.
Royal Iced Cookies – $5.95 each
Brownies & Bars – $3.75 each

Pies & Crisps (by Special Order)

Chocolate Malted Pie*
Lime Pie *
Banana Pudding Pie*
Buttermilk Pie
Peanut Butter Pie*
Cheesecake*
Cherry Almond Pie
Mom’s Apple Pie
S’Mores Pie*
Apple Crisp

Fall/Winter Selections:
Southern Pecan Pie
Pumpkin Pie*
Crunchy Caramel Apple Pie
Apple-Cranberry Crisp

10” Pies – $38
10” Fruit Crisps – $35
Pie by the slice – $6.25
Cheesecake 9” – $45
Cheesecake 3”- $5.75
Hand Pies/Mini Pies (Apple, Cherry or Mixed Berry) – $4.50 each.
Minimum Special Order: 1 dozen per flavor

*Requires refrigeration